| 1 | Standards and specification compliance | 18% | Whether the proposed coating system meets the project’s applicable requirements for pipe type, service, and environment. Standards such as AWWA C213 or ISO 21809-2 may be relevant to particular applications; applicability depends on the project specification. | Compliance matrix, current test reports, product data sheets, and documented exceptions or deviations. |
| 2 | Coating performance and durability | 15% | Evidence that the coating’s specified properties suit the intended exposure, including corrosion protection, adhesion, impact resistance, and resistance to relevant chemicals or temperatures. | Test methods and results tied to the specified coating system and service conditions; qualification records where required. |
| 3 | Surface preparation control | 14% | Control of steel cleanliness, surface profile, dust, oil, moisture, and other conditions before coating. Surface preparation requirements should follow the governing project specification. | Written procedures, inspection records, instrument calibration records, and batch or shift-level preparation logs. |
| 4 | Application and curing process control | 12% | Consistency of powder application and control of relevant process variables, such as pipe temperature, coating thickness, and cure conditions, in accordance with the approved procedure. | Process-control plans, production records, equipment maintenance logs, and calibration certificates. |
| 5 | Inspection and testing capability | 10% | Ability to inspect the finished coating using the methods and acceptance criteria stated in the contract, including checks for thickness, continuity, and visible defects when specified. | Inspection and test plans, sample inspection reports, calibrated equipment records, and procedures for handling nonconformities. |
| 6 | Pipe size and configuration range | 9% | Capability to coat the required pipe diameters, lengths, wall thicknesses, and specified fittings or end configurations using an approved process. | Documented production range, equipment limits, representative project records, and confirmation of any size-specific constraints. |
| 7 | Quality management and corrective action | 8% | How the supplier controls documented procedures, inspection records, nonconforming product, corrective actions, and process changes. | Quality-system documentation, audit findings and closure records, and examples of corrective-action reports. |
| 8 | Traceability and documentation | 6% | Ability to link supplied pipe and coating records to production batches and provide the documentation required for project handover. | Sample material and coating records, batch identification procedures, inspection dossiers, and document-retention practices. |
| 9 | Handling, packaging, and delivery controls | 5% | Measures to reduce coating damage during storage, loading, transport, and site handling, plus the ability to meet the agreed delivery schedule. | Packing and handling procedures, inspection records before dispatch, delivery plans, and damage-claim processes. |
| 10 | Technical support and warranty clarity | 3% | Availability of technical support for specification review, coating repair guidance, and clear written warranty terms relevant to the supplied product. | Support contacts, repair instructions, warranty document, and stated exclusions or claim requirements. |