| Facility identity and scope | Confirm the legal entity, physical production site, and activities it performs, such as formulation, filling, packing, or testing. | Business registration details, facility address, manufacturing permits or records applicable to the product and jurisdiction, and a written scope of work. | Match the legal name and site address across records, contracts, audit documents, and product paperwork. Ask whether any production step is subcontracted. | Documents consistently identify the same site and clearly define its role. | Unexplained differences in site names, addresses, or production responsibilities. |
| China NMPA product status | For products intended for the Chinese market, determine whether the product is a general cosmetic or a special cosmetic and whether the applicable filing or registration has been completed. | Relevant NMPA filing or registration information, product details, and the identity of the domestic responsible person where applicable. | Search the relevant public NMPA records and check that the product type, responsible party, and product details correspond to the documents provided. | Regulatory status can be independently checked and matches the product being offered. | A supplier treats a factory certificate as proof that every product is registered or filed. |
| Ingredient and safety review | Check the complete formula, ingredient names and concentrations, intended use, and the product safety assessment applicable to the target market. | Full ingredient list, formula version history, raw-material specifications, safety assessment documentation, and supplier or batch records for ingredients. | Have a qualified regulatory or safety reviewer assess the formula against current requirements in each intended market. Confirm formula changes are controlled and reviewed. | Formula records are complete, version-controlled, and supported by documented safety review. | Only a marketing ingredient list is supplied, or formula details are withheld without a suitable confidentiality process. |
| Cosmetic GMP practices | Assess controls for personnel hygiene, premises, equipment, cleaning, production, quality control, storage, and documentation. | Current quality manual or procedures, recent audit report, training records, cleaning logs, batch records, and deviation or corrective-action examples. | Review records and, where possible, conduct an on-site or independent audit. Check that procedures are followed in actual production records. | Documented procedures are supported by traceable, completed records. | Procedures exist only on paper, or requested records cannot be linked to real production batches. |
| ISO 22716 certification | If the manufacturer claims ISO 22716 certification, check the certified site, activities, certificate validity, and certification scope. | Complete certificate showing the standard, covered site, scope, issue and expiry dates, and certification body. | Confirm the certificate with the issuing certification body. Check that its scope covers the relevant cosmetic manufacturing activities. | Certificate is current and verifiable for the production site being assessed. | Certificate is expired, unverifiable, or covers a different site or activity. |
| Other management-system certificates | Review any claimed quality or environmental certificates without treating them as proof of cosmetic product approval. | Certificate number, standard, covered site and scope, validity dates, and issuing certification body. | Verify status with the certification body or its public directory. Compare the certificate scope with the work the supplier will perform. | Certificate is authentic, current, and relevant to the stated management system. | A general management certificate is presented as a substitute for product-specific regulatory compliance. |
| Testing and product quality | Confirm that testing is appropriate to the formula, packaging, use, and destination market. Relevant checks may include microbiological quality, stability, and packaging compatibility. | Test protocols and reports, sample identification, methods, laboratory details, acceptance criteria, and records of out-of-specification results. | Check that reports identify the tested sample and method. Confirm the laboratory’s competence and accreditation scope where accreditation is claimed. | Reports are product-specific, traceable, and assessed against documented criteria. | Generic reports are supplied without sample details, methods, or clear acceptance criteria. |
| Claims and efficacy evidence | Check that product claims are supported by appropriate evidence and comply with the rules of the intended market. For China, review applicable efficacy-claim evaluation and disclosure requirements. | Claim-by-claim substantiation, supporting study or test reports, approved artwork, and relevant public disclosure records where required. | Compare every proposed label, website, and advertising claim with the supporting evidence and current market-specific rules. | Claims are specific, evidence-based, and consistent across product materials. | Therapeutic or guaranteed claims are made without suitable evidence or regulatory review. |
| Batch traceability and release | Verify that finished goods can be traced to production records and relevant raw-material batches, and that release follows documented quality checks. | Sample batch manufacturing records, raw-material lot records, finished-product release records, and recall or complaint procedures. | Ask the supplier to trace a sample batch from incoming materials through production, testing, release, and distribution records. | Batch records are complete, linked, and retrievable; release responsibilities are clearly assigned. | Batch codes cannot be connected to production or quality records. |
| Change control and subcontracting | Establish how changes to formula, ingredients, suppliers, processes, packaging, or production sites are reviewed and approved. | Change-control procedure, sample change records, approved supplier list, and list of subcontracted activities or sites. | Confirm that changes require documented assessment and customer notification where agreed. Verify subcontractor controls and responsibilities. | Changes are documented, assessed, and approved before implementation. | Supplier can change formula, materials, or production site without notice or traceable approval. |